Based on the research by Slim Kohler and Don Ware, your Remington New Model Army revolver's delivery date to the Ordnance Department would have been (approximately) during March 1864, as part of the contract of Nov. 21, 1863. Deliveries that month totalled 4000 units and would have been serial numbered in the range of 59205 through 65800.
Hope this helps in your search, and please think about signing up as a member for a year.